PRO 1: contemporary sources rarely distinguish them. 2. Pres. Samuel Brown appears in both (at different times). CON 1. no other members in common. 2. geographic clues point in two very different directions.
entity #480495, assertion #4004481 by bplewe on 2018-02-11: confidence 0%.
PRO 1. at least 6 families in common, including the 1847 Branch President. 2. Big Spring never mentioned once Carterville starts to appear in autumn 1848. 3. names mixed together in 1850 census. CON 1. on 8/6/1848 HPM p.5, both branches appear in the same list.
entity #480730, assertion #4004480 by bplewe on 2025-02-06: confidence 80%.
Gardner Snow, William Gardner of "Big Spring on Musqueto," Chauncey W. Porter "of same" are high priests, July 2 1848, Only source where Big Spring and Carterville are mentioned on the same day, but not both called branches.
entity #850431, assertion #3772678 by bplewe on 2025-02-06: confidence 100%.
"Spring Branch on Muskeeto Creek" organized, May 8 1847, President E.M. Greene, Lyman Stoddard visiting authority; members Moses Tracy, David Colvin, Orlin Colvin, William Carter, Elisabeth Heward, Levi Savage
entity #700102, assertion #4004477 by bplewe on 2025-02-06: confidence 100%.
notes:This branch is clearly separate from the other Big Spring, but it has several members in common with Carterville, including the 1848 bishop and president. Almost all mentions of this branch are before any mentions of Carterville. Thus it is likely that Big Spring either turned into or was merged into Carterville Branch.
assertion #3716223 by bplewe on 2025-02-06: confidence 100%.
FamilySearch:KWNT-73J
, Started:8 May 1847
, Ended:between 1848 and 1849
, Source Image
, Source:Evan M. Greene Diaries, V.6 p.91, Church History Library MS 1442
, Source:mp:700102
Appears to have been president of Big Spring and Carterville at the same time; same branch?
FamilySearch:KWVM-3QX
, Started:15 Jul 1848
, Ended:between Aug 1848 and Sep 1848
, Source Image
, Source:Pottawattamie High Council Minutes, Church History Library LR 1764 21, folder 1 p.105
, Source:mp:850383
Appears to have been bishop of Big Spring and Centerville at the same time; same branch?